Things That Make Me Go Hmmmm….

Learning How to be a Critical Thinker

A Return to Critcal Thinking October 18, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — ndphinney @ 9:59 pm

How it has changed the way I use media…

Before tackling this capstone essay, I went back to our Week 2 materials to revisit Dr. Richard Paul’s “Critical Thinking in Everyday Life: 9 Strategies.” When I started this class, I made it a personal goal to try and incorporate many of these strategies into my daily life in order to hone my critical thinking skills and bring them up to a level that is appropriate to a doctoral scholar.

Out of curiosity, I decided to click on the link that gave me a biography on Dr. Richard Paul. Something that I noticed now that I did not notice before I started taking this class was that the information page on Dr. Paul was quite vague. It stated that he has received “four degrees”  but it failed to go into detail about what the degrees were in, where he got them from, or when (what year) he got them. A few weeks ago, I decided to blindly follow the strategies of someone whose expertise I never decided to question or investigate. internetdog

Now, that being said, I do believe that Dr. Richard Paul is legitimate, and I will continue to incorporate these nine strategies into my daily life. However, something that I have learned from this class is that you must ALWAYS verify the credibility of the information that you read, take in, and quote. Furthermore, this goes beyond the internet. This rule of thumb applies to any sort of media or medium that one procures information from. Anyone can write a book. Anyone can write a blog or start a website. Anyone can be a wolf in sheep’s clothing, which I think is something that everyone learned from viewing the Martin Luther King Jr. website. The age of self production of information is both a blessing and a curse- we all become our own gate keepers and news makers, but not everyone who opens the gate or writes the news is free from bias, and this is an issue that we need to address through critical thinking skills.

How it has changed my own professional practice…

Because I am not yet a full fledged Media Psychologist, I can only imagine how it will change my professional practice. However, I do know that it will and already as changed how I encourage my friends, family, and fellow scholars to engage with media. My usual reply of “well, just Google it” has now become “Well, you could just Google it, but make sure that it is valid information. Who wrote the site? Is it legitimate? Do you have all of the information? Did you verify it with a secondary credible source? Make sure you check a couple different sites, and just because it’s at the top of the search page doesn’t mean that it’s a good source!”

In my last blog, I made reference to the “tepid romance between social media and critical thinking.” I believe that this will be a theme for me in my future practice as a Media Psychologist. Being connected is wonderful, but part of what I want to accomplish is helping people understand the difference between being connected and being too connected. I believe that it is a complicated game of give and take that requires critical thinking skills.

sm-cartoonAs human beings, we want to be connected to those around us, and we want new and advanced ways to make our crazy and complicated lives much simpler. New advances are great, but at what point do we rely upon technology so much that it acts as the third element in our human communications? In our eternal quest to become more connected, can we actually push ourselves further away from human interaction? As a Media Psychologist, I want to help people understand that there is a fine line, and we can learn how to approach it carefully by way of critical thinking skills. Before we adapt a new technology we must carefully evaluate it from a critical perspective to judge if this particular technology will actually help us- or will it add yet another task to our complicated daily to do list? Will it actually accomplish what I want it to do? Will it make my life simpler or will adding that extra step make my life more complicated? Before people wholeheartedly adapt, I want to help them react.

How critical thinking will inform my ongoing research and scholarly development during this Media Psychology doctoral program…

First and foremost, I will put everything that I read or take in under a scholarly microscope. I will always verify the credibility of the information that I incorporate into my research and writing. This is important on both a scholarly and personal level. On the scholarly level, I want the work that I produce to be credible. I want my peers to take me and my work seriously, so I owe it to myself and the scholarly community to make sure that I use valid and credible information and sources. On a personal level, much like on the scholarly level, I owe it to myself to do my best with this program, and part of doing my best includes producing the best work that I am able to produce. PeerReviewCartoon

I want what I do to become a drop in the pool. When I produce scholarly work, it is placed into the scholastic universe, and who knows who will read what I write. Who knows who will quote what I wrote. Another topic that we discussed in this class was the dissemination of truth on the internet. If I am going to produce scholarly work and “put it out in the world” I want it to be truthful.

If anything, this class has taught me that I need to have the highest standards for my work. I need to utilize critical thinking in not only my scholarly work, but my day to day life.

And, for a final thought, digest this…

All cartoons from www.cartoonstock.com, a paid subscription service.

 

Social Media October 11, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — ndphinney @ 10:54 pm

There is an old saying that “no man is an island.” In 2009, that saying has never been more true. Social media has put us (as human beings) in the position of being connected to the tEcosystem virtually everywhere we go. I think that it goes without saying that social media is going to, or really, has already changed our lives. However, I think the bigger question that we have to ask ourselves is, “Is social media going to change our lives for the better?”

People are, by nature, social human beings. We naturally build social circles and possess family heirarchies. There is an inherant desire to be connected to those that we love and care for. In the past we stayed in touch with family and friends by way of postal mail and telephone. People have a need to live within a constant conversation of friends and family- both talking and listening through the tEcosystem. Social media affords individuals to function as a constantly connected island, a place where we don’t need a common space to connect, but we create our own spaces and reach out to those around us. Will Richardson said it best when he spoke about this island becoming the new way that we approach technology. We will no longer be on a physical island- we will be able to go anywhere, talk to anyone, and learn almost anything through social media.

However, we also have to consider the other side of the story. In our desire to become completely connected, can we become too connected? Can we depend so much upon social media that we have no real need or desire to interact with human beings? Lore Sjoberg (video above) makes a vaild point- after a while, using social media just produces a mash up of human communication which gets output as a synthetic bit of communication.

It seems now that we as Media Psychologists are charged with a large task. Part of what we do will be to help individuals learn how they can connect to the limitless world around them. However, another part of our task will be to help individuals stay personally connected in an increasingly digital world.

(Video courtesy of Wired Magazine, embedded through YouTube.)

 

Consumer Psychology October 4, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — ndphinney @ 3:52 pm

Like many other lessons I have learned while in this class, my biggest take away for this week stems from me believing that I know more than I actually know.

2006-07-12I tend not to think too long and hard about what is happening when I watch a commercial on television, or hear an ad on the radio. Perhaps this is how advertisers want it to happen- If I hear an advertisement for Crest toothpaste, the jingle or hook line is tucked away in my subconscious level and it will be the first thing that I recall while standing in the toothpaste isle in Target.

Or maybe not.

Like many other industries, the advertising industry is struggling with the ideas from and the boundaries of modern technology. It is not possible for every single toothpaste company to make an advertisement that will stay lodged in my brain, so they all try harder and work faster to be the stand out advertisement in a sea of advertisement clutter. As a result of wanting to be the one stand out advertisement, the advertising industry is depending more and more on the psychology of consumers, and making us want something more than we think we want it. Putting a model in a Crest commercial amongst a smiling group of friends and family is a design to make us look for the bigger picture. People will want to be friends with me if I have white teeth and a nice smile, and if I’m happy, my family will be happy. Crest toothpaste gives me white teeth and a nice smile, so I need to buy Crest so I can have more friends and a happy family! Crest Toothpaste Ad 1978 snapshots

Crest toothpaste is a pretty tame example, but it is happening all across the board with many different products. Advertisers are appealing to consumers on a deeper level- you have a desire for this product because it will fill a need that you do not yet know you have, or know why you have it.

The Frontline episode “Merchants of Cool” was particularly enlightening to me. The advertising industry is putting forth a great deal in cracking the code of an up and coming group of consumers: teenagers. Group think mentality combined with lack of responsibility and great amounts of disposable income means that advertisers are fighting fast and hard to get their hands on the money of teenagers- simply because they have the money to spend and getting them young will (hopefully) ensure brand loyalty.

(All cartoons/images used with permission.)

 

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.